Jill Tuck: Good or Evil?

[Wolverine]

After seeing Jill in SAW 5, what do you think, is she good or evil?

[IBelongToHoffman]

I love Jill, but that's probably because I've actually had a personal conversation with Betsy Russell and she was really nice

As for good or evil, I think she is just trying to honor her husband's last wishes. In VI we see her give something to someone in package form (Most assume a video tape) and I think this is her trying to send evidence to someone. Also, she did try to kill the Hoff.

~Monica

[Dark Vader]

I love Jill, but that's probably because I've actually had a personal conversation with Betsy Russell and she was really nice

~Monica

I Find That Hard To Believe..................Anyways, Jill Tuck Is Like A Woman Who Was Once Good, Turned Bad And Turned Good But The Bad Personality Still Lingers!

[Ayla]

I think and still think she's essentially good. She allowed what John was doing but never supported it. She possibly rigged Hoffman's reverse bear trap but I think that's because either the trap demanded it or because she was swayed emotionally by the note Pamela gives her. I don't think anyone could call her evil.

[GameOver83]

I'm still not too sure as of yet whether I believe that she's truly good or evil, despite the fact that she is Jigsaw's ex, it doesn't neccesarily mean that she'll follow straight in his footsteps...We'll just have to wait & see ^^

[Jigsaws_apprentice]

I believe she is good and wouldn't harm anyone , unless it was for her husband who she is clearly devoted too... she loves him more than anything and will do anything for him... but she also has her morals... suspose you can shes both really.

[GnrlGothic]

Good... Evil... that's so black and white, no one is 100% evil or 100% good, Jill is good-hearted, for sure, but I think she's able to do some bad things dedicated to John, since she clearly cares about him.
But then again, I don't think John is evil... If by good/evil you mean: supporting Jigsaw or not supporting Jigsaw, then I'd say evil.

[jIgPaW]

She seemed on the Good side to me(: It's not like she liked doing some of John's dirty work, anyways~

[HeHelpedMe]

Good.

[Valkarius]

I would say good. Because well, she I guess wanted to somehow repay John. He did avenge Gideon and she kept his secrets till his death. Okay, she isn't completely innocent yet not necessarily evil.

Betsy Russell played her in a support role after all. And I am pretty sure she (Jill) tried to help John. She even tried to get Hoffman yet hesitated when he woke up. That or felt remorse like she didn't want to kill him. As I saw the fear in her eyes yet she was somewhat happy. Because of the fact, she'll be with Gideon.